Big Ten Basketball Is Overrated

AP Photo

The Big Ten is rated as the best conference by the Ratings Percentage Index (RPI), a primary tool used by the selection committee. That is not unique, and I would say that every objective ranking system I have seen has the Big Ten at #1 based on the results this year. Ken Pomeroy’s and Jeff Sagarin’s ratings both have the Big Ten with 4 of the top 9 teams, and 8 of their 12 teams inside the top 50.

Consensus would seem to pretty solidly put the Big Ten at #1 looking at the depth and average rating of the conference. So why do I think they are probably overrated? Because almost every team rated as the “best conference” is overvalued based on a relatively small sample size of results, most of which occurred in November and December.

Before I get into some...

Read Full Article »

Recommended Articles

Big Ten Could Get 9 NCAA Tourney Bids

Dave Ommen, Beyond the Arc - January 31, 2012

Kentucky and Syracuse remain No. 1 and No. 2 on the s-curve in this week’s bracket.  That scenario may not change when the actual Field of 68 is announced on Selection Sunday.  Wildcat fans can start making ... more »

Big Ten Superior to SEC in Integrity

David Whitley, Sporting News - February 4, 2012

When it comes to the really cutthroat aspects of the business, no conference should want to be like the SEC. Just look at the most recent ways, shapes and forms of Les Miles and Nick Saban. Miles got in front of a booster club... more »

May Madness? Push Back College Basketball

Dan Wolken, Fox Sports - January 31, 2012

This was supposed to be college basketball’s Big Year, its once-in-a-generation moment when older stars (at least by one-and-done-era standards), historic teams and a weakened, post-lockout NBA conspired to drive interest in... more »

'Inexcusable' Call Dooms W. Virginia

Mike Casazza, Charleston Daily Mail - January 29, 2012

West Virginia did what it needed to do to tie Saturday's game against No. 3 Syracuse and a point-blank shot with 8 seconds to go had everyone on the sideline jumping and screaming -- but for all the wrong reasons. WVU's Deniz... more »