On Thursday, the American League will announce the recipient of its Most Valuable Player award. The winner is likely to be Miguel Cabrera, the Detroit Tigers star who won the league’s triple crown by leading in batting average (.330), home runs (44) and runs batted in (139).
It might seem as if these statistics make Cabrera, the first triple crown winner in either league since 1967, a shoo-in for the M.V.P. But most statistically minded fans would prefer that it go to another player, Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels.
The argument on Trout’s behalf isn’t all that complicated: he provided the greater overall contribution to his team. Trout was a much better defensive player than Cabrera, and a much better base runner. And if Cabrera was the superior ...
Read Full Article »
Recommended Articles
Rick Hummel, St. Louis Post-Dispatch - November 12, 2012
Only two previous catchers have led the National League in batting average in a season and one of them, Cincinnati’s Ernie Lombardi, was named the league’s Most Valuable Player in 1938 after hitting .342.
Lombardi ... more »
Joe Posnanski, Sports on Earth - November 12, 2012
First, a little history. The thing that makes the Rookie of the Year fundamentally different from the other awards, I think, is that, like wine* and REM albums, there are good years and bad.
*So I’m told. I... more »
Lyle Spencer, mlb.com - November 13, 2012
There was never any doubt about Mike Trout as Rookie of the Year. The only question is whether he's the Rookie of All Time.
"I've been in the game 30-something years, and I've never seen anyone like him," said Oakland general... more »
Ben Reiter, Sports Illustrated - November 2, 2012
Is free agency dead in baseball? Not entirely, though this winter will feature fewer potential franchise-changers than in years past, for two related reasons.
One is that several clubs who could previously be counted upon to... more »
Mike Berardino, South Florida Sun Sentinel - November 2, 2012
Here's what the Marlins won't be getting with Mike Redmond as their next manager.
Marketing sizzle.
An outsized personality suitable for cable TV reality shows.
The experience of having managed a World Series winner somewhere... more »