Contentious MVP Vote Validates Cabrera

Robin Buckson/Detroit News

One group of voters mattered more than the writers in awarding Miguel Cabrera his American League Most Valuable Player Award during Thursday's dramatics in New York.

The players.

After the most divisive, most acidic, debate I can remember in my baseball experience, Cabrera beat a glorious rookie, Mike Trout, for the 2012 AL MVP plaque.

An official vote confirmed it. Twenty-two of 28 ballots from Baseball Writers Association of America members had etched Cabrera's name into that first-place slot. Six had chosen Trout. Victory for a Tigers superstar, the first Triple Crown winner in 45 years.

But what made this vote, and this sadly polarized discussion, less of an argument and more of a validation, was last week's release of the Players Choice...

Read Full Article »

Recommended Articles

In Stat Analysis, It's Trout Over Cabrera

Nate Silver, Five Thirty Eight - November 15, 2012

On Thursday, the American League will announce the recipient of its Most Valuable Player award. The winner is likely to be Miguel Cabrera, the Detroit Tigers star who won the league’s triple crown by leading in batting... more »

Airtight Case for Posey as NL MVP

Alex Pavlovic, San Jose Mercury News - November 15, 2012

The instructions at the top of the National League Most Valuable Player ballot begin with the words: "There is no clear-cut definition for what Most Valuable means." In 2012, Buster Posey did his best to change that. Posey ... more »

Why Posey Should Be NL's MVP

Rick Hummel, St. Louis Post-Dispatch - November 12, 2012

Only two previous catchers have led the National League in batting average in a season and one of them, Cincinnati’s Ernie Lombardi, was named the league’s Most Valuable Player in 1938 after hitting .342. Lombardi ... more »

Perez Was More Than Guy Who Got Lost

Chuck Culpepper, Sports on Earth - November 3, 2012

It took me too long in life to comprehend that life is absurd and that nobody really knows much of anything and that if anybody tries to tell you they know much of anything, they're often similar to a rich clown praying from a TV... more »