Best Players Not in the Hall of Fame


Every couple of years during Hall of Fame season, I like to revisit an idea that was inspired by Bill James, identifying the top players at each position who remain outside the gates of Cooperstown. The concept is a nod to James’ systematic Keltner Test, which is named for former Indians third baseman Ken Keltner, a seven-time All-Star who’s best known for his defensive work in helping to end Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak in 1941. James’ test is a set of 15 questions that can be used to frame a player’s case for Cooperstown. One of the most important: “Is he the best player at his position who is eligible for the Hall of Fame but not in?” 

Given the recent elections of players such as Roberto Alomar, Bert Blyleven, Barry Larkin and Ron Santo who could make...

Read Full Article »

Recommended Articles

Baseball Prospecting an Inexact Pursuit

Joe Posnanski, Joe Blog - December 25, 2012

Bill James wrote a piece the other day about the possible difference between pitching and hitting prospects … and it reminded me of this project I've wanted to do for some time. I wanted to go back through Baseball America's... more »

How Boog Powell Brought Mom and Me Together

Joe Posnanski, Joe Blog - December 26, 2012

My mother, as I have written many times before, knows and cares nothing about baseball. She used to care nothing of any sport outside of the Olympics, but in recent years she has become more interested in these silly games, and... more »

New Addition Hanrahan to Close for Red Sox

Evan Drellich, - December 27, 2012

There will be no closer competition. Andrew Bailey, Boston's presumed ninth-inning man for 2013, has been moved to a setup role in favor of the centerpiece of Wednesday's six-player trade with Pittsburgh, right-hander Joel... more »

Looks Deceive: Hard to Fathom Freel's Death

John Fay, Cincinnati Enquirer - December 25, 2012

One play summed up Ryan Freel's career. The Reds were playing one of the last games of spring -- it may have even been the very last game. It was in Clearwater against the Phillies. Freel was playing center field. A ... more »

Memories of the 'Eccentric' Freel After Suicide

Anthony Castrovince, - December 24, 2012

When I think of Ryan Freel, I think of Farney.   Farney was the imaginary little man living in Freel's head. He was the reason, apparently, why it was not at all odd -- for those of us who had the pleasure of being around Freel... more »