A Troubled Hall of Fame Process


Okay, let’s be clear here. Nobody got snubbed in the Pro Football Hall of Fame voting. It’s an exclusive award, not a hall pass, and anyone who whines that their guy got hosed need only look at the seven enshrinees to understand that the issue was, is, and will always be about the process.

Eddie DeBartolo got some support in the room, very little pushback, but was among the first cuts from 17 candidates to 12, according to one selector who asked – well, insisted – on anonymity. Tim Brown got little debate pro or con. And Charles Haley got a fair level of support but was canceled out by the number of defensive linemen on the ballot, of which only Warren Sapp cleared the wall.

The real problem, though, remains as it has been – the funnel for players is too...

Read Full Article »

Recommended Articles

Modell Doesn't Belong in Hall of Fame

Gregg Doyel, CBS Sports - February 3, 2013

 NEW ORLEANS -- Art Modell isn't a Hall of Famer, and it has nothing to do with what he did to Cleveland in 1996. He's not a Hall of Famer because he wasn't all that good at being an NFL owner. It's as simple as that. Or at... more »

Parcells Leads 2013 Hall of Fame Class

Benjamin Hoffman, New York Times - February 3, 2013

NEW ORLEANS — Bill Parcells, the only coach to lead four teams to the playoffs and the winner of two Super Bowls with the Giants, highlighted a class of seven inductees to the Pro Football Hall of Fame on Saturday. Joined... more »

49ers Complete Long Road Back

Jim Trotter, Sports Illustrated - January 21, 2013

 ATLANTA -- For years he had dreamed of the moment, and when it arrived early Sunday evening Frank Gore was nearly speechless. He stammered for a moment, with no consistent train of thought. Then he smiled wide."I don't know... more »

Flacco Answers His Critics

Mike Wise, Washington Post - January 21, 2013

FOXBOROUGH, Mass. — Unacknowledged as a real counterpart to Tom Brady, unconvincing in his quest for platinum membership in the NFL quarterback club, unemotional, unfunny — often unloved by many of his own fans — Joe Flacco... more »

Pats Come Up Empty in Another Super Quest

Jeff Howe, Boston Herald - January 21, 2013

FOXBORO — The quest for a fourth Super Bowl has again been put on hold. The chance for Tom Brady to match Joe Montana’s ring count in harmonious fashion against the 49ers wasn’t to be.For just the second time in the... more »