RealClearSports
Advertisement

Fantasy Football Maniaxs


September 28, 2009 11:39 AM

Applaud or a Fraud - Fantasy Football injury replacements in Week 3

Each week, we'll comb through the stat sheets to identify fantasy football performances of note. Then we'll try to analyze these performances to see if these players should be applauded or if they're a one-week fraud. As we do this, we'll focus on players that are start/sit decisions for most fantasy owners or players who are on many waiver wires. Note that not all verdicts mean the same thing. Some mean pick the player up or let him stay on the waiver wire; others mean start the player or leave him on your bench. The report beside each player spells out our thinking.

We list injury replacements from Week Three in this post. You can read our applaud or a fraud analysis of all fantasy football positions and many more players whose names you need to know now on www.footballrelativity.com, along with a lot more fantasy football and general coverage of the NFL.

--

Quarterbacks

Kyle Boller, Rams - I've always had a soft spot for Boller, who seemed to play well every time I saw him in a Ravens uniform. He stepped in for an injured Marc Bulger vs. the Packers and threw for 164 yards and two touchdowns, which aren't bad numbers. It's hard to picture a scenario in which Boller is worth starting in your fantasy league, but if Bulger's shoulder injury is significant, Boller might merit backup-QB consideration in larger leagues (12 teams minimum). Otherwise, just ignore this new starter. Verdict: A fraud

Chad Henne, Dolphins - Henne took over when Chad Pennington had to leave the game with an injury to his throwing shoulder. Now Pennington is out for the year, and that means that Henne isn't a terrible backup option. He completed 10-of-19 passes for 92 yards with one pick and one sack. Henne won't put up Kevin Kolb-ish fill-in numbers, but he's a safe bet to throw for 175 yards or more, probably with a touchdown. So Henne is one of the better options among the fill-in quarterbacks. This is very mild applause, but still... Verdict: ApplaudSeneca Wallace, Seahawks - Matt Hasselbeck tried to play against the Bears this week, but in the end he couldn't go with a broken rib. So Seneca Wallace took his place and threw for 261 yards and a touchdown. Wallace started eight games last year and threw for 11 TDs and 1,500 yards, so he can be productive. If he plays next week against the Colts - which is not a sure thing, given how close Hasselbeck was to playing Sunday - Wallace has fantasy value, if for no other reason than the fact that the Seahawks will likely find themselves behind on the scoreboard. Verdict: Applaud

Read more about QBs Jason Campbell, Derek Anderson, and Josh Johnson at www.footballrelativity.com

Running backs

Glen Coffee, 49ers - Coffee, a rookie out of Alabama, really hasn't gotten untracked yet this season, and he averaged less than 3 yards per carry in his 54-yard day taking over for Frank Gore against the Vikings. But with Gore likely to miss two games or more, Coffee is a legitimate starting running back who's worth a pickup in your league and maybe even a start against the Rams next week depending on your other options. In fact, both his Week 4 matchup against the Rams and his Week 5 game against the Falcons are favorable. Grab Coffee if he's available, and don't rule him out of your lineup without some consideration this week. Verdict: Applaud

Jerome Harrison, Browns - With Jamal Lewis inactive, the Browns turned to Harrison instead of rookie James Davis to carry the load. Harrison did post 52 yards, but it took him 16 carries to do so. Our suggestion that you avoid any and all Browns definitely applies here. Verdict: A fraud

LeSean McCoy, Eagles - The rookie from Pittsburgh got a clear shot at starting for Philly this week with Brian Westbrook inactive, and McCoy responded with 84 yards and a touchdown. When Westbrook is inactive, McCoy is a starting option in all fantasy leagues. But if Westbrook does what he's done in the past and plays most weeks despite being listed as questionable, McCoy will be a more difficult guy to turn to. Still, McCoy is a necessary insurance policy for Westbrook owners, and he has some fantasy value on his own given Westbrook's tendency to get dinged. Verdict: Applaud

Read more about RBs Ahmad Bradshaw, Julius Jones, and John Kuhn at www.footballrelativity.com

Wide receivers

Pierre Garcon, Colts - Garcon, more than rookie Austin Collie, has stepped up and produced with Anthony Gonzalez injured. He has scored two weeks in a row now, and this week he was a consistent offensive threat with three catches for 64 yards. While Gonzalez is out - which is for several more weeks - Garcon is definitely ownable and even startable if you're in a bye week pinch. Verdict: Applaud

Read more about WRs Bryant Johnson, Santana Moss, Greg Lewis, Mike Wallace, and Kevin Walter at www.footballrelativity.com - You'll also find info on TEs Vernon Davis and Daniel Fells and PK Olindo Mare

A Member Of